Having a dog fence in your yard is one of the most important things to have. Especially when you want to keep them on your property without them roaming free. They certainly deserve to have their own space to roam around and play (and rightfully so).
We have a few more options that you can choose from aside from the top pick on our list. You can choose a dog fence based on the overall budget. There are also some other things to consider so you can better choose a dog fence that fits your personal preferences.
If you are interested in learning more about our top pick or any of the additional dog fences that we’ve handpicked out of the many products during our analysis, keep reading. We will provide you with an overview of each product including the pros and cons. Also, you can use the buyer’s guide below to help you through the buying process so you know which dog fence will be the absolute best option.
However, choosing a dog fence can be a challenge. After analyzing 21 products and 875 consumer reviews in a span of 25 hours, we whittled down some of the best dog fences currently on the market. Our favorite is the Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen.
Table of Contents
Dog Fence Comparative Table
SMALL DOG PICK
|Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen|| ||9.4/10||See price on Amazon|
|SportDOG In-Ground Invisible Fence|| ||9.2/10||See price on Amazon|
|AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen|| ||8.8/10||See price on Amazon|
Our Pick for The Best Small Dog Fence
The Best for Small Dogs
With a double latch step-through door, it’s easily accessible for both you and your dog. The exercise pen comes in different heights and widths, which will vary depending on the breed of dog. It also has ground anchors, corner stabilizers, and thumb-snaps to ensure the easiest assembly possible.
Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen Video Review
What We Think of The Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen
Easy to assemble, easy to access, and not just for dogs. Those are the three things we can come up with in terms of what we think about this dog fence. But to take it a little further, we can say it is the best option for you if you are looking for excellent durability.
That’s because it has an e-coat finish that won’t wear out easily. Putting this together without the use of tools might just be the best thing ever. Because it will take minutes to assemble, not hours.
The assembly is pretty self explanatory. You just set up the fence, put the stabilizers and anchors in places, snap on the fasteners and you’re done. Quick, easy, and no fuss.
Get this. It works and it’s solid. It also packs up small for traveling.
Before you know it, your dog will have a ball inside of this exercise pen whether it’s indoors or outdoors. It’s also easy to disassemble and is portable. So if you need to go somewhere with your dog, you can take this with you and easily load it into the trunk of your vehicle.
The setup will obviously be easy enough. For the price it’s going for, it’s definitely worth every penny. It might not be the most affordable in your budget, but the price and value do match each other.
Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen Specifications
- Brand: Midwest
- Height: 24 inches
- Width: 24 inches
- Assembly: Toolless
- What’s included: 8 ground anchors, 8 corner stabilizers, 4 thumbscrews
- Finish: E-Coat Finish
- Square Footage (Assembled): 16 feet
Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen Pros and Cons
- Easy assembly
- Excellent durability
- Great for small breeds
- Portable for travel
- Noisy on hardwood floors
- Can get knocked down easily
- Not great for indoor use
- Some breeds may outgrow it after awhile
Our Final Opinion about the Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen[usrlist Quality:4.7 Effectiveness:4.7 Design:4.7 Price:4.3]
It’s better for this fence to be used outdoors rather than indoors. But nevertheless, the Midwest Foldable Metal Exercise Pen/Pet Playpen gets the nod for best overall for a few good reasons. It’s ease of assembly and portability makes this one of the best in the business.
Our Outdoor Pick for a Dog Fence
The High Performance Pick
If you are looking for a dog fence that does not require not just assembly, but the parts themselves, the SportDog In-Ground Invisible Fence might be a great option. It’s easy to install, but it works with a rechargeable collar that your dog will need to wear. Especially if they love roaming outside and cover a lot of ground in the process.
SportDOG In-Ground Invisible Fence Video Review
What We Think of The SportDOG In-Ground Invisible Fence
This is a godsend for anyone who doesn’t want to buy a fence that requires a lot of assembly. It can cover as little as 1 ⅓ acres of land and no more than 100 acres. So if you have a good amount of land on your property, this might be the best option.
It’s a heck of an upgrade considering the price that it’s going for. You get a transmitter with a collar to ensure that your dog will stay in the ‘fenced area’. The collar will have a beep or a buzz warning that will go off, which is safe for the dog but will gently let them know that they are getting close to the edge.
The collar itself fits dogs that are ten pounds and up. There are additional collars that can be fitting for an unlimited number of dogs. Whether you have one, two, or even four you will have a collar for each. What else makes this invisible fence so special?
I live on an acreage with a major highway nearby. I dug this into the ground and wrapped the remaining wire around a fence on my property. My dog responds very well to this.
This features a transmitter that is equipped with a wire break alarm and is protected from lightning strikes. So the good news is that it will work even if it withstands the worst weather conditions that nature can throw at you. To know that it has this kind of protection should give you peace of mind.
You get a charging cable, an alert system letting your dog know that they need to stay within the area without hurting them, and the easiest installation possible. For the price that it’s going for, you better believe that it’s fitting for our upgrade pick.
The battery life of the collar will last about two months at maximum. This is the fence for you if your dog wants the ultimate freedom to move around. Especially when you have plenty of land on your property.
SportDOG Invisible Fence Specifications
- Brand: SportDog
- Height: N/A
- Width: N/A
- Assembly: Toolless
- What’s included: Rechargeable collar, rechargeable dog collar, transmitter
- Finish: N/A
- Square Footage (Assembled): Minimum 1.75 acres, maximum 100 acres
SportDOG Invisible Fence Pros And Cons
- Easy for dogs to respond to
- Alert systems don’t hurt the dog
- Excellent coverage area
- Provides dogs with plenty of freedom to run around
- Collar buckle design may be inconvenient for daily wear
- Warning beep can be inconsistent
- Adjusting the shock level may be tough
- A bit expensive
Our Final Opinion About the SportDOG Invisible Fence[usrlist Quality:5 Effectiveness:5 Design:4.5 Price:4]
While one of the more expensive options, the Sport DOG Invisible Fence earns the top performance pick for its overall reliability. It can help even the most stubborn dogs be trained properly to know where the perimeter is. Other than that, if you have the land and the money, this should be sufficient.
Our Budget Pick for a Dog Fence
The Budget Pick
Obviously, you may be looking at the possibility of purchasing a dog fence that may be budget friendly. The best possible option is the AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen. This can be usable both indoors and outdoors. And it is useful for dogs that stand out at about 20 inches in height.
Made from iron metal and a rust proof finish, it’s excellent protection and durability for a dog fence that can surely stand the test of time. If anything, this is the best dog fence that you can afford in terms of overall quality. Way better than going for cheap and sacrificing quality in the process.
AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence PenVideo Review
What We Think of the AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen
On paper, it may look like it’s thin and lightweight. So you may worry about it tipping over easily. But rest assured that won’t be the case. It’s about 20 pounds, so it will take a much larger dog to push it over with ease.
It’s got excellent durability thanks to the iron metal and the black finish that will protect it from rust. Whether you take this indoors or outdoors, it has the potential to last you quite awhile. Not bad for a budget pick. For the price it goes for, you know for a fact that you’re getting a pretty good deal on quality and reliability.
This comes with a total of eight connected panels, measured out at about 30 by 24 inches. Once assembled, you will have a space of well over 25 square feet. This is the perfect space that you’ll need for dogs that are small to medium size breeds. If you have a Cocker Spaniel, French Bulldog, or even a Chihuahua, this is the perfect exercise fence.
I’m very happy with this. Used this when camping with my three dogs. They are all small and under 20 pounds. It was high enough that they didn’t even try to jump out. Easy to set up and set it into a circle or square.
The setup is pretty easy. And even better, it requires no tools. All you need to do is connect the metal panels together and you’re finished.
This also gives you the flexibility to change it into various shapes. It can be a circle, rectangle, or square. The more space it can provide for your dog, the better.
But what if you just want to go somewhere with your dog? Obviously, you can because it’s easy to disassemble and easy to pack in your vehicle. Portability will be a plus especially if you and doggy like to move around all the time.
AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen Specifications
- Brand: AmazonBasics
- Height: 30 inches
- Width: 30 inches
- Assembly: Toolless
- What’s included: 3 metal thumb clips, 8 ground anchors (outdoor use)
- Finish: Black coating
- Square Footage (Assembled): 25 square feet
AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen Pros And Cons
- Great for small and medium breed dogs
- Easy setup
- Affordable for most budgets
- Very durable
- Not the best for indoor use
- No door threshold
- Metal may bend easily
- Can damage wooden floors
Our Final Opinion About the AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen[usrlist Quality:4.5 Effectiveness:4.9 Design:4.8 Price:5]
If you want something simple and affordable, the AmazonBasics Foldable Metal Pet Dog Exercise Fence Pen is the clear choice. It’s a good option for small and medium sized dogs and is surprisingly durable even for a budget pick.
Alternative Products to Consider
PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence for Dogs Review
The Best for Stubborn Dogs
For dogs that may have a hard time listening to your commands, this fence could be what you need to ensure they know what the boundaries are. If they are stubborn or even hearing impared, this is the fence that will help them roam around freely while knowing where to go and where not to go.
It’s safe for dogs and customizable so they can have as much as 25 acres of land to roam around in. Plus, the collar is adjustable so it can fit all kinds of dogs.
PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence for Dogs Video Review
What We Think of the PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence
We get it. There are some dogs out there that may be hard to train compared to others. And it certainly can be a stressful thing to do.
You may also have a dog that loves to roam around but may not be responsive to commands that will get them to come over to you. Rest assured, the PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence might be the best solution. It’s an excellent alternative to standard dog fences, which the sight of them can drive a dog nuts (especially one that has a hard time calming down).
So if you are looking for a fence that will help them stay within their boundaries without them freaking out at the sight of a regular fence, you’d be insane not to consider something like this. There are four levels of adjustable static intensity that won’t harm the dog.
What makes this even special is that it will work for dogs that are hearing impared. The coverage area ranges from 1.33 acres to 25 acres if you purchase additional wires and flags. The more land that you have, the more wires and flags you might need, which comes at an additional cost. A necessary evil, but worth the investment. The collars are easy to adjust and guaranteed to provide a comfortable fit.
The collar and the fence system itself is waterproof. So it can handle the bad weather days quite well. Whether it’s rain or shine, the PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence can definitely work wonders
Installing the wires underground will be easy and you won’t need to dig deep. If you have a weekend free to yourself, this might be a good project for you to do. You can train your dog to know the boundaries of the fence within two weeks.
My Great Pyrenees would NOT stay home. She would roam around with the other neighbourhood dogs and chase after cars. After installing this fence and wearing the collar for a couple of months, she wouldn’t cross the boundary. She stays where she needs to be even without the collar on. The best purchase for my dog and my peace of mind.
Once all is said and done, your dog will be given total freedom to move around. And if they go a little too far, they will be alerted. It takes patience and training on your part. But when done right, your dog will get the message each time they get a little too close.
Wireless fences seem to be all the rage these days and for good reason. And with a collar that won’t shock and terrify your dog, this might just be the next best thing in dog training. Especially when you want to give them as much freedom as possible to roam around.
PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence Specifications
- Brand: PetSafe
- Height: N/A
- Width: N/A
- Assembly: Transmitter, underground wires (additional wires and flags sold separately)
- What’s included: Adjustable waterproof collar, flags, wires, plug-in adapter
- Finish: None
- Square Footage (Assembled): Minimum 1.33 acres, Maximum 25 acres
PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence Pros and Cons
- Affordable for a wireless fence
- Decent coverage
- Perfect for stubborn or hard of hearing dogs
- Can last a long time after installation (i.e — a few years)
- Install isn’t as straightforward
- May be inconsistent at times
- The range can be iffy
- May not be lightning resistant
Our Final Opinion About the PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Fence[usrlist Quality:4.9 Effectiveness:4.8 Design:4.3 Price:4.4]
This invisible fence has the potential to last a long time provided that you charge the battery on a regular basis. This is excellent for such breeds known for being stubborn such as Australian Shepherds, Brittany Spaniels, and similar breeds. It’s waterproof and can definitely withstand the soggy days even if the dog loves to run around outside.
No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack Review
The No Assembly Pick
At a total of 116 inches, it’s two different fences that you can put together as one super large fence for the outdoors. No digging, easy assembly, and very aesthetically pleasing regardless of where you put it.
If you have small pets, this is the perfect fence to have for the outdoors.
No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack Video Review
What We Think of No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack
This is one of the alternatives that you can look at if your budget is something you don’t want to compromise on. Unlike some of the fences we have reviewed thus far, there is no digging needed for installation. You can easily put this together in minutes and have a beautiful looking fence for your outdoor area.
This comes with two units, totalling out to about 116 inches of fencing. You could install two different fences or combine them into one giant fence if you have plenty of space (especially in your backyard). When putting this all together, all you need to do is plant your stakes into the ground.
The picket fence style makes it appealing and looks like it is part of your home. Who says you cannot have a picket fence in your home? Easy to install and also easy to combine, your dog will have plenty of space to roam around.
Fence was easy to set up and works great for its intended purpose. It also keeps the dog out of the raspberry bushes.
Dogs of almost any size can benefit from this fence specifically for the amount of space that is allowed. Just make sure you have a backyard that’s large enough and you’ll be in business.
The fence is made from premium vinyl, making it very sturdy and durable. It comes with ground stakes, which means there is little to no cleaning involved or even getting dirty for that matter. The fence will stay in place and won’t easily get knocked over. It’s the perfect choice if you’ve tried different fences but the knockovers have become a source for frustration.
No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack Specifications
- Brand: Zippity Outdoor Products
- Height: 30 inches
- Width: 58 inches
- Assembly: Toolless
- What’s included: Adjustable waterproof collar, flags, wires, plug-in adapter
- Finish: Vinyl
- Square Footage (Assembled): N/A
No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack Pros and Cons
- Keeps dogs within boundaries
- Does a good job keeping outside ‘invaders’ away
- Easy installation
- Very aesthetically pleasing
- Constant adjustments may be needed due to wind
- Pickets may not stay in at times
- Quality is a bit flimsy
- No pre-drilled holes to make installation a lot easier
Our Final Opinion About the No-Dig Vinyl Picket Garden Fence 2 Pack[usrlist Quality:4.4 Effectiveness:4.6 Design:4.9 Price:4.7]
Whether you want to use two fences or combine them into one great big fence, there is no denying that this fence is among the most customizable on the list. Best of all, it requires no assembly whatsoever. Which is a huge plus for those who want to waste no time with putting something together.
Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard Review
The Large Areas Pick
If superwide is what you want, you’ll get exactly that with the Regalo 192-inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard. Obviously, it’s usable so long as you have a great deal of space. Which is exactly what dogs want. It can be assembled in a straight line or shaped and angled.
No tools are required for this assembly as it is quick and easy. It can be used both indoors or outdoors. And you get the best security and peace of mind with safety lock features.
Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard Video Review
What We Think of Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard
Once assembled, you get a fence of up to 192 inches. That is about 16 feet in total fencing. The best way to install this is obviously making sure you have a large enough room. This could go well in an entryway outside of your living room, which is usually one of the largest rooms in your home. Or you could have a large enough backyard where you can assemble this and shape it into a circle, square, or rectangle. Standing 28 inches in height, it’s the perfect option for any size dog. It doesn’t matter if it’s a Shih Tzu or a Husky. Even though it is much lengthier than other fences, it’s easily portable.
You can assemble it and disassemble it easily. Once it’s folded up, it can be stored inside the trunk of your car. Just because it’s 192 inches in length, doesn’t mean it won’t fit.
If you’re worried about your dog simply escaping, the good news is that you shouldn’t. That’s because it has a durable and very reliable safety lock. You can get in and out with ease. But you better make sure that the safety lock is engaged to prevent those dastardly escapes.
Good quality. Although this is heavier than the plastic alternatives, it’s sturdier and has vertical bars that can’t be easily climbed. You can add or remove individual panels to make it just the right size”
The fence is made from steel, which makes it very sturdy and durable. If durability is what you’re looking for, then this fence might meet your standards. Easily mount the ends to the wall or bring the panels together, giving you absolute flexibility on how you want it set up.
Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard Specifications
- Brand: Regalo
- Height: 28 inches
- Width: 192 inches
- Assembly: Toolless
- What’s included: 8 panels, space bars, safety lock
- Finish: Steel
- Square Footage (Assembled): 16 feet
Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play YardPros and Cons
- Perfect for multiple purposes
- Great for all dog breeds
- Makes it very hard for dogs to climb
- Very sturdy
- Junctions are a little weak
- May scratch walls or door frames
- May be a little wobbly in the middle
- Cap heads and plastic can melt over the screw
Our Final Opinion About the Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard[usrlist Quality:4.8 Effectiveness:4.5 Design:4.7 Price:4.8]
This is obviously the clear pick for best for large areas. Whether it’s indoors in a living room or outside with a big backyard, the Regalo 192-Inch Super Wide Gate and Play Yard is definitely worth the investment if you want to make sure that your dog has all the space in the world to play in.
PAWLAND Wooden Freestanding Foldable Pet Gate For Dogs Review
The Indoor Rooms Pick
Attractive wood finish, superior sturdiness, and perfect for the indoors and outdoors. You can simply open and close this with ease without worrying about the dog escaping from it. It can fit in doorways and hallways without inflicting damage to the frames and walls.
What We Think of The PAWLAND Wooden Freestanding Foldable Pet Gate For Dogs
If you want simplicity, this gate has that. Simple to install, simple to use, and simple to prevent dogs from jumping over it. At about 24 inches in height, it’s perfect for small and medium sized dogs.
The wooden finish makes it perfect for indoor use. It’s wide enough to close off hallways and doorways, so long as you give your dog plenty of space to roam around. It folds up like an accordion, which means there is no assembly and disassembly required. And yes, let’s not forget that portability will definitely be in question whenever you want to take it with you. It’s light in weight and certainly easy to carry with you for a simple setup every time.
This is the perfect size for keeping our puppy safely confined to an area where she can stay in one area with me. It’s stylish and very durable. She hasn’t chewed on it or tried to knock it down.
The non-slip rubber feet will not only keep the gate sturdy, but it will prevent any damage being done to your floors (especially hardwood floors). If you are looking for a stylish dog fence for indoor use, look no further.
PAWLAND Wooden Freestanding Foldable Pet Gate For DogsSpecifications
- Brand: PAWLAND
- Height: 24 inches
- Width: 60 inches
- Assembly: Fully assembled
- What’s included: 4 panels
- Finish: Wood
- Square Footage (Assembled): Varies by room
PAWLAND Wooden Freestanding Foldable Pet Gate For Dogs Pros and Cons
- No assembly required
- Excellent for the indoors
- Very attractive look
- Super sturdy
- Not suitable for outside use
- Cannot be used for big dogs
- Hinges are a bit questionable in quality
- A bit expensive
Our Final Opinion About the PAWLAND Wooden Freestanding Foldable Pet Gate For Dogs[usrlist Quality:4.6 Effectiveness:4.6 Design:4.7 Price:4.3]
This is to our knowledge the only ‘indoor-only’ fence that will work great. Especially for small and medium breeds. It’s quaint, looks like it can blend in with the rest of the house, and it has a touch of class. Not too shabby if you want something that requires no time to put together since it’s fully assembled.
Why Should You Trust Us?
All our recommendations on The Good Choice are the result of many weeks or months of research, comparisons, analyses of user’s ratings and if need be, interviews with experts and scientists. You will quickly notice that the products we suggest here are not the most expensive or the most trendy: they are those that will best perform their daily tasks, passing all security, reliability and efficiency tests while having an appealing price-quality ratio for everyone.
In the end, the products we recommend are those we would have wanted to buy, or those we will choose for our friends and family.
Things to Know Before Buying a Dog Fence
What type of fencing is best for dogs?
Most dog fences that are made from metal, vinyl, wood, and other solid materials will work very well for dogs. This type of fencing is great for dogs that are easily distracted by people or other dogs. Wood fences in particular provide you with extra privacy and overall value to your home.
Which is better: wireless or wired dog fences?
Wireless dog fences are a lot easier to install. But it may not be as reliable as you want if you have less than ¾ acres of land. If you do not have a lot of land on your property, you may opt for a wired dog fence.
How do you bury an invisible fence?
An invisible fence can be buried fairly easily using a flat-edged shovel. Be sure to dig a narrow trench that is as wide as the shovel itself. Continue this until you are able to mark out the perimeter of the area you want the fence to cover.
How to Properly Choose Your Dog Fence
Choosing a dog fence can be a challenge. Especially when you have to choose between a wireless fence or a regular fence. Your final decision will come down to a few factors that will eliminate most of the fences that don’t meet your criteria while keeping some others intact.
Let’s take a look at the following:
Indoors or Outdoors?
While most of the fences are useful both indoors and outdoors, some of them may be strictly used for either or purpose. If you plan on taking your dog outdoors for some fresh air and an abundant amount of space to run in, then you can choose a fence that will be perfect for outdoor use.
Large fences can be better set up outside while some of the smaller fences can be used for indoor use. If set up indoors, you want to make sure it is able to stay in place and not damage any of your interior surfaces like walls and floors.
Invisible or Paneled?
If you are looking for an easy set up, a paneled fence might be a good enough type. However, if your dog has a habit of being stubborn and running around a lot, odds are that an invisible fence could work.
Keep in mind that an invisible fence will only work if you have ¾ acres or more or land. Otherwise, it won’t be as reliable. If you live in a suburban neighborhood, obviously the best choice would be a paneled fence such as the No Dig Picket Garden Fence.
The price may be a good factor. However, it should not be the only reason why you purchased it. If you are staying within a certain budget, decide which prices will be the base and the ceiling. That will give you enough room to choose a fence that can be chosen based on other factors like overall quality and function.
The material may vary. But at the end of the day, it comes down to sturdiness. If you are looking to put a fence outside, you want something made from durable materials like steel or vinyl. Some woods or even faux wood won’t survive water exposure, thus making it suitable for indoor use only.
The measurements will vary from one fence to another. Consider the breed of your dog for example. If you want something for a large breed dog, obviously a higher fence height will be sufficient as they won’t be able to jump over it. Likewise, a shorter height will be sufficient for smaller dogs but again, it should be high enough for them to prevent jumping.
In terms of width, take into consideration how much space is appropriate for your dog to move around in. Don’t restrict them to a small amount of space. If need be, you can consider something like the Regalo 192 Inch Super Wide Dog Fence if you have plenty of space in your house.
We do our best to provide you with a comparative guide of dog fences allowing you to choose the best product possible. If we are missing information or new models, do not hesitate to leave a comment below or to send us a message.